Digital resources in the Social Sciences and Humanities OpenEdition Our platforms OpenEdition Books OpenEdition Journals Hypotheses Calenda Libraries OpenEdition Freemium Follow us

A Political Dreamer: Giorgio La Pira as an intermediary between the Vatican and the Soviet Union, 1951–1965

By Viktoriia Serhiienko

The text is based on a lecture delivered at the French Institute in Rome on January 15, 2026.

The Catholic Church is currently in the process of beatifying Giorgio La Pira (1904–1977), who served as mayor of Florence in 1951–57 and 1961–65 and as a cultural ambassador of the Vatican to the Soviet Union and vice versa. In Italy, numerous studies — often bordering on hagiography — have been published about il sindaco santo (“the holy mayor”). By contrast, in the post-Soviet space (if the use of this now somewhat outdated term is still warranted), there is an almost complete absence of both scholarly publications and living memory concerning La Pira. Is this asymmetry merely coincidental?

This article addresses the following questions: Why did the Roman Curia, from which the very inception of the socialist movement had systematically purged the Catholic Church — especially in Italy — of what it perceived as a new heresy, come to support La Pira?1 What factors contributed to his transformation, in the eyes of the Vatican, from a marginal and politically undesirable figure under Pope Pius XII — who criticized him for abandoning “clear moral principles” — into a key intermediary in relations with the Soviet Union after Pius’s death? And finally, what role did La Pira’s mediation play in the Catholic Church’s broader rethinking of itself — not as an extension of the West, as had largely been the case during the early Cold War, but as an institution with interests distinct from those of the West?

To answer these questions, I will examine the figure of Giorgio La Pira not so much in the context of Italy’s international politics—which has already been extensively addressed in the historiography — but rather in relation to the Vatican’s policy toward the Soviet Union. Although the latter often aligned with Italy’s foreign policy, it nevertheless pursued its own distinct objectives.2

Two people in black and white, shaking hands and laughing
Italian politician Giorgio La Pira and Father Jean Daniélou in Piazza della Signoria, Florence, June 1953. Obtained via Wikimedia Commons.

From Marginal Figure to Vatican Intermediary

It has already been forgotten that at the onset of the Cold War, figures such as La Pira had very limited influence within the Vatican, while the Holy See’s official newspaper, L’Osservatore Romano, openly condemned his political stance. However, following the death of Joseph Stalin in the spring of 1953, hopes emerged that tensions between the two blocs might ease. This shift, combined with the election of Giovanni Gronchi (1887–1978) as President of Italy in 1955, contributed to a notable change in the Vatican Curia’s attitude toward the left wing of the Christian Democrats.

These developments coincided with a generational shift within the Vatican that had begun during the final years of Pius XII’s pontificate and crystallized under Popes John XXIII and Paul VI. The emerging generation was described by contemporaries as “progressive,” in contrast to the more conservative “integrists.” As the progressives gained influence, Vatican policy toward the USSR underwent a significant transformation. Left-leaning Christian Democrats, known as the “professorini” — including Giorgio La Pira (1904–77), Giuseppe Dossetti (1913–96), and Amintore Fanfani (1908–99) — were instrumental in this process. Among them, Giorgio La Pira was a pivotal figure in the implementation of soft power, seeking to establish ties between the Vatican and the Russian Orthodox Church. In doing so, he often turned a blind eye to the tragic circumstances of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church in order to avoid provoking discontent among the Soviet authorities and preserve the broader strategy of Vatican–Soviet dialogue.

La Pira’s First Mission to the Soviet Union

In August 1955, during a congress of mayors that he organized in Florence, La Pira spoke about peace in rhetoric that was comprehensible to the Soviet Union. He hosted high-ranking Soviet guests, including the Soviet Ambassador to Rome, Alexander Bogomolov, and the Mayor of Moscow. The results of the congress were evaluated very positively by the Soviet Ministry of Foreign Affairs. It was noted that the decisions made in Florence were “close in nature to the resolutions of the Congresses of Peace Supporters,” which served as instruments of Soviet soft power. Consequently, La Pira was invited to visit the Soviet Union. However, probably due to opposition from Pope Pius XII, the trip did not take place. He received a second invitation under Pope John XXIII. Ultimately, in 1959, La Pira became the first Western non-Communist politician to visit the Soviet Union. He described the purpose of his visit as follows:

“Well, that is precisely why I am going: to pray for the conversion of Russia and for the peace of the nations, all of this in view of the great ecumenical council which, as the Pope said, “will move heaven and earth.” Archivio Giorgio La Pira (Florence).”3

Before his journey to Moscow, he performed a series of ceremonial gestures: he received blessings from conservative cardinals, visited the town of Fátima, and traveled to Coimbra, where Sister Lúcia resided.4 She stated that she would pray for his intentions but politely declined to receive him. During his trip to the Soviet Union, prayers for him were offered in Catholic monasteries around the world.

How did this visit become possible? By the late 1950s, there was a sense that the Cold War had reached an impasse. This period saw the denunciation of Stalinism at the 20th Congress of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union in 1956, the beginning of détente on the international stage, and a shift in the competition between the two opposing political blocs toward the economic sphere, symbolized by the emergence of the European Economic Community. At the same time, Italy was seeking opportunities to enhance its own standing on the international stage, giving rise to the idea of “neo-Atlanticism.” This policy involved maintaining Italy’s membership in NATO while simultaneously pursuing dialogue with countries of the so-called “Third World” and with the states of the socialist bloc. During this period, the Soviet Union adopted a realpolitik approach toward Italy, setting aside ideological considerations and the interests of the Italian Communist Party in favor of the USSR’s state interests. These interests centered on maintaining personal contacts with the leaders of the governing majority within the Italian government. 5

Peacemaker or Political Instrument?

So, what role did La Pira play in all this? A peacemaker, a saint, or an unwitting tool of the Soviet Union, which exploited his pride and illusions? One way or another, it can be stated with certainty that La Pira reflected the views of a segment of the Italian political establishment, society, and the Roman Curia toward the USSR. It is important to note that neither in his meetings and conversations with Soviet officials nor in his letters to the Roman pontiffs and cardinals did La Pira mention the fate of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church. It appears that this issue was largely unknown to him and of little interest, given his broader ambitions as a mediator in the fulfillment of the Fátima prophecy concerning the conversion of “Russia” to Catholicism.

His letters make it evident that he ignored the existence of Ukraine altogether, even when in Kyiv, which La Pira considered a Russian city. His rather superficial Russophilia was easily reinforced by traditional Soviet practices of cultivating politicians, ambassadors, and others—giving expensive icons as gifts, organizing impressive receptions, and arranging introductions to members of the metropolitan cultural elite. For example, the KGB assigned the Ukrainian writer Mykola Bazhan to La Pira, tasking him with acquainting La Pira with the life of the artistic elite. In a lengthy letter, he addressed Khrushchev as follows:

“I firmly believe in the great Christian rebirth of Russia, within the new economic and social reconstruction.” Ibid. 6

And this was precisely at the time when Khrushchev had launched yet another anti-religious campaign, which lasted from 1958 to 1964. It is also unclear whether La Pira knew or was concerned about the fact that Khrushchev himself had been responsible for the liquidation of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church in 1946. At that time, Khrushchev held the highest political office in Soviet Ukraine, and he was the one who decided how the Church would be eliminated.

During his visit to Kyiv, La Pira expressed sympathy for the fate of the Kyiv Pechersk Lavra, much of which had been destroyed in 1941. He was told—and believed—that the cathedral on the monastery grounds had been destroyed by the Germans, whereas in reality its destruction had been planned by the Soviet authorities.

La Pira demonstrated knowledge of a few individual saints and hierarchs important to the Russian Orthodox Church, but he did not recognize the distinctiveness of the Kyiv tradition of Christianity at all. He failed to notice these differences because his knowledge was superficial. After all, where could he have deepened it, given that even the Jesuits of the Collegium Russicum, established to train missionaries for the USSR, did not possess any greater expertise? La Pira was transported from capital to capital under the close supervision of a KGB handler and lived under surveillance in hotels. Yet he believed that he had managed to see the “real USSR.” Overall, this appears to be a fairly typical reaction of someone whose head had been turned by a sense of having a special mission.

Similarly, in 1944, the American priest of Polish origin, Father Orlemanski, was used by Roosevelt and Stalin for their respective purposes: the former for his reelection campaign and to cultivate a favorable image among Polish Catholics in the United States, and the latter to present an attractive image of the USSR as a state tolerant of the Church rather than as a country of militant atheists. Once, on the eve of the terror of the 1930s, Stalin published an article in Pravda entitled “Dizziness from Successes.” Something of the same phenomenon can be observed in each of these privileged visitors to the Soviet Union.

Upon his return to Florence, La Pira, in his excitement, shared with journalists a telegram from Cardinal Tardini’s secretary, which was simply a courteous display of politeness. However, La Pira believed that the Holy See had blessed the completion of his journey. When the Holy See distanced itself from this “unbalanced and dangerous friend,” as Tardini put it, La Pira responded to him as follows:

“The only one who had the courage (an act of faith) to introduce the religious question into the current great phase of détente in political relations between nations, as a question that concerns the peace of peoples, was I! This poor and insulted La Pira had the courage to go right into the bear’s den and say—in the very heart of the Kremlin—that Christ is the problem of problems, the Key that opens the doors of peace, the Alpha and the Omega of history!” Ibid.7

He portrayed himself as a gladiator or a Christian martyr fighting wild beasts. In a longer letter to Pope John XXIII, he continued in an exalted tone, recounting his conversation with Metropolitan Nikolai Yarushevich—incidentally, a KGB agent directly involved in the liquidation of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church:


“That conversation—Blessed Father—had constituted one of the most essential pages of my life (which, to be sure, is not lacking in eventful and vivid pages!): I felt as though I were living in the time of St. Paul, in a living scene from the Acts of the Apostles; and an immense hope was born in my heart! A dream? Naivety? Sentimentalism? No, I am (in a certain sense) sure of it: grace could be touched with one’s hands, as they say; I was living a vital experience of the life-giving Spirit!” Ibid.”8

At the same time, recently published archival documents from the Soviet Ministry of Foreign Affairs indicate that La Pira played a significant role in facilitating contacts between Italian President Giovanni Gronchi, Italian Prime Minister Amintore Fanfani, and the Soviet leadership. He also acted as an intermediary between the Vatican and the USSR on the eve of the Second Vatican Council. It was through La Pira’s conversation with Senator Luciano Mencaraglia that rumors reached Moscow that Pope John XXIII intended to invite hierarchs of the Russian Orthodox Church to the Council.

Memorial plaque on a yellow wall. with the writing, in italian, "Here GiorgioLa Pira was born son of Pozzallo and citizen of the world.'
Plaque placed on the birthplace of Giorgio La Pira in Pozzallo. “Son of Pozzallo, Citizen of the World.” Obtained via Wikimedia Commons.

La Pira’s activities reveal the complex interplay between religious conviction, political ambition, and diplomatic pragmatism in the Vatican’s evolving relationship with the Soviet Union. His legacy thus raises broader questions, Namely: How important is thorough prior knowledge of the historical, cultural, and political context of a region before entering peace negotiations? Where is the boundary between genuine peacemaking efforts and the mere simulation of peace talks, which only serves to delay conflict resolution? What continuities can be discerned in the policies of Italy and the Vatican toward Russia, Ukraine, and Eastern Europe more broadly?


About the Author:
Dr. Viktoriia Serhiienko is a researcher at the German Historical Institute in Warsaw. In 2014, she completed her PhD at the Department of History at Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv, with a thesis titled “Formation and Activity of the Orthodox Church Brotherhoods of Left-Bank Ukraine (1864–1917).” Dr. Serhiienko’s research focuses on the religious and social history of Central and Eastern Europe in the 19th and 20th centuries. Her most recent work examines the history of Russophile and Ukrainophile movements in eastern Slovakia between the two World Wars. Dr. Serhiienko is currently involved in an international research project focused on the pontificate of Pope Pius XII, titled “The Global Pontificate of Pius XII: Catholicism in a Divided World, 1945–1958.”


References:

1 One need only recall the Vatican’s political suppression of Catholic communists in Italy, its disapproval of the French prêtres-ouvriers movement in the 1940s and 1950s, or its condemnation of Liberation Theology that emerged in Latin America in the 1960s.

2 With regard to the sources used in this paper, I will primarily draw on Giorgio La Pira’s private archives in Florence, but will also rely on the Russian State Archive of Contemporary History, the archives of the Polish Ministry of Foreign Affairs, as well as documents declassified in 2020 from the pontificate of Pius XII, held at the Archives of the Society of Jesus (ARSI) and the archives of the Congregation for the Oriental Churches in Rome.

3 “Ebbene vado proprio per questo: per pregare per questa conversione della Russia e per la pace delle nazioni: e tutto ciò in vista del grande concilio ecumenico che, come il papa disse, “commuoverà cielo e terra”.”

4 The prophecy of Fátima consists of three secrets revealed by the Virgin Mary to three shepherd children – Lucia dos Santos and her cousins Francisco and Jacinta Marto.

5 For more details see: Alessandro Salacone, “Le relazioni italo-sovietiche nel decennio 1958–1968. Uno sguardo da Mosca,” Storicamente, accessed October 28, 2026, https://storicamente.org/ms/dossier-doss_italia_urss/salacone.

6 “Io credo fermamente nella grande rinascita cristiana, entro la nuova edificazione economica e sociale, della Russia.”

7 Il solo che ha avuto il coraggio (atto di fede) di introdurre nella attuale grande fase distensiva dei rapporti politici fra le nazioni il problema religioso come problema che interessa la pace dei popoli, sono stato io! Questo povero ed insultato La Pira ha avuto il coraggio di andare proprio nella tana dell’orso e dire – in pieno Kremlino – che Cristo . il problema dei problemi, la Chiave che apre le porte della pace, l’alfa e l’omega della storia”

8 “Quel colloquio – beatissimo Padre – aveva costituito una delle pagine piu essenziali della mia vita (che pure non manca di pagine movimentate e vive!): mi sembrava di vivere al tempo di San Paolo: ad una scena vivente degli Atti degli Apostoli: ed una immensa speranza nacque nel mio cuore! Sogno? Ingenuit.. Sentimentalismo? No, ne sono (in certo modo) sicuro: la grazia si toccava con le mani, come si dice: vivevo una esperienza vitale dello Spirito vivificante!”


Citation: Dr.Viktoriia Serhiienko, A Political Dreamer: Giorgio La Pira as an intermediary between the Vatican and the Soviet Union, 1951–1965. TRAFO – Blog for Transregional Research. 3.04.2026 from https://trafo.hypotheses.org/70013

Forum Transregionale Studien
Forum Transregionale Studien
The Berlin-based Forum Transregionale Studien promotes the internationalization of research in the humanities and social sciences. It provides scope for… Read more

The text only may be used under licence Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial No Derivatives 4.0 International. All other elements (illustrations, imported files) are “All rights reserved”, unless otherwise stated.


OpenEdition suggests that you cite this post as follows:
Forum Transregionale Studien (November 3, 2026). A Political Dreamer: Giorgio La Pira as an intermediary between the Vatican and the Soviet Union, 1951–1965. TRAFO – Blog for Transregional Research. Retrieved November 11, 2026 from https://doi.org/10.58079/1723b


You may also like...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.